|
Online Petition to Protest Against the Govt Policies on FDs and PAN
Created by
Dignity Foundation on April 5, 2010, 12:55 pm in Economy and Business |
Online Petition to Protest Against the Govt Policies on FDs and PAN
Please register your protest against the current fiscal policies on your FDs and transactions based on PAN
There are four issues of concern, especially to senior citizens:
1. Under a Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) circular, banks have been asked to deduct tax in advance per quarter on accrual basis. ref. Sucheta Dalal.
According to another CBDT circular, of March 2, 2010, No income tax at source will be deducted if banks have only made a provision for interest on fixed deposits and not actually paid it to the depositor. It further clarified that since no credit is given to the depositors while calculating interests on fixed deposits on daily or monthly basis in the CBS software used by banks, tax need not be deducted at source on such provisioning of interest.
2. Banks and other entities accepting FDs, deduct tax at source in advance on the full interest paid once it exceeds Rs.10,000 p.a. If there is no tax liability, the investor submits Form 15H requesting non deduction, with an affidavit on their income being below the basic exemption limit after deductions. Since tax is paid only on taxable income beyond the basic exemption limit, deducting tax at source for the whole income leads to excess tax deducted, with the assessee having to claim a refund.
3. The rule requiring all to obtain and quote Permanent Account Number (PAN) comes into force effective April 1, 2010. Failure will hereafter attract TDS at a penal rate of 20% against a normal 10% if the assessee fails to quote the same in all financial and tax transactions.
4. With the new Direct Tax Code effective April 1, 2011, is it fair, a person earning just above 25 lacs a year, pays a tax at 30% - the same 30% applicable for one earning several crores a year? Should not there be another slab for those earning, say above 2-3 crores a year, in the form of an additional 5% tax at least, considering senior citizens in the age group of 70 years plus, have paid tax at a marginal rate of 93% in the socialist 70s on their sealed annual income of 50,000 and also had to keep aside 10% for Compulsory Deposit Scheme(CDS)? This was refunded in dribs and drabs only after a 10 year period when its value, with inflation over this period, being reduced to not 'nil' but 'negative'!
|
|
| Petition's Target: Protest Against the Govt Policies on FDs and PAN |
| Petition's Goal: We are am inviting maximum number of people to support. |
| Petition's URL: http://www.indianvoice.org/online-petition-to-protest-against-the-petition.html |
|
|
|
| Recent Signatures |
View All Signatures |
| 42. | 3 days ago P.R.Narayanaswami I support this petition. |
| | 41. | Saturday, last week RAJAGOPAL I support this petition. |
| | 40. | 1 month ago Sandip Debnath I support this petition. |
| | 39. | 1 month ago Prashanth I support this petition. |
| | 38. | 1 month ago Neethashree I support this petition. |
| | 37. | 1 month ago Neethashree I support this petition. |
| | 36. | 1 month ago shobha jain I support this petition. |
| | 35. | 1 month ago raj kumar jain I support this petition. |
| | 34. | 1 month ago R N Rastogi I support this petition. |
| | 33. | 1 month ago Ramgopal Cancherla I support this petition. |
| | 32. | 1 month ago T.V.Rajeevan I support this petition. |
| | 31. | 2 months ago B N Srinivasa Rao I support this petition. |
| | 30. | 3 months ago L N Roychoudhury I support this petition. |
| | 29. | 3 months ago Paresh I support this petition. |
| | 28. | 3 months ago M.S.Ramachandran I support this petition. |
| | 27. | 3 months ago AMIT I CAN NOT support this petition. |
| | 26. | 3 months ago Prashant C Chaturvedi I support this petition. |
| | 25. | 4 months ago Bommakanti Jagan Mohan I support this petition. |
| | 24. | 4 months ago SHASHIKANT SHIRAHATTI I support this petition. |
| | 23. | 4 months ago Thyagarajulu K I support this petition.
K Thyagarajulu |
| | 22. | 4 months ago anjani I support this petition. |
| | 21. | 5 months ago ASIM KUMAR SEN I support this petition. |
| | 20. | 5 months ago GCP I support this petition. Why should any senior citizen pay any tax on any savings. Through out the life, they have paid taxes. and when it comes to old age, when they do not have any income, but only savings will be the source of livelihood, why does government need to tax their savings... |
| | 19. | 5 months ago Vishwas Shankar Sabnis I support this petition. |
| | 18. | 5 months ago gundurao nagesh I support this petition. |
| | 17. | 5 months ago Josi Cherian Basically PAN numbers is required to be obtained by a person whose income falls in the taxable limit and is liable for income tax payment.
Form 15- H is a form submitted by a person not having taxable income.
Hence both of these are normally not going together. So the logic of tax deduction @ 20% for those not having PAN number is illogical.
If the government actually wants all persons to have a PAN number, why don't we make it compulsory for all to have a PAN Card or issue a PAN card with address and biometric identification and then insist on this being used for all bank accounts/ transactions etc.
Another aspect is that this probably can avoid the TDS formalities since all payments are recorded towards a PAN number and government / income tax department can trace these payments clearly and claim tax on these.
Instead it is not logical to insist on TDS at source where the banks / companies making payment have to do a lot of extra work to deduct/pay and submit and upload TDS information etc without getting any compensation. ( Doing the work of IT dept without getting paid for it)
One more point is about the refund of excess tax paid, where the IT dept has been left free by the government with no answerability. They take their own time to make the refund and sometimes the refund cheques are not sent out, waiting for the assesses to come and collect it against a tip etc. Can an order be passed that the refunds are despatched from IT department within 6 months from the date of filing of returns if there are no querries and also put a deadline for seeking querries and disbursing the case within one year. |
| | 16. | 5 months ago Mani Bharucha I support this petition. |
| | 15. | 5 months ago V.Subramanian I support this petition. |
| | 14. | 5 months ago Shirish I support this petition. |
| | 13. | 5 months ago Doraiswamis We support this petition.Our protest is on the unfair burden imposed on middle class, especially senior citizens, lack of clarity in directions & insufficient thought given to avoidable consequences, without corresponding awareness programme.
1. Almost as if to manage shortfalls in corporate direct tax collections, imposing TDS on bank FDs - the only avenue prefered by most senior citizens - in advance of bank interest payment is immoral , leading to erosion of capital even before interest payment starts.
2. Clarifications needed on how banks will manage to make good exess TDS made on provisional interest in the previous years.
3. Mandatory PAN, while ideal, is******** senior citizens who have nil / low tax and are unaware of consequences of not having one, as PAN is generally thought, mistakenly yes, to be only for tax payers. It not only imposes penal rate of 20% TDS on non - compliance but one has also to quote it in all financial & economic transactions, including Form 15H for non-deduction of tax, Income Tax Returns, refunds claims, sale of moveable & immovable property, correspondence, bills, vouchers, documents and many more. To be subjected to such harsh measures, without simultaneously providing a non-cumbersome and quick mode of issue of PAN cards, like through their own banks and post offices, who can verify the necessary details , is both thoughless & inhumane.
4.Getting refunds is not as easy as the press releases suggest, as our own experience shows. We have five due, despite many reminders.
5. Not every one has access to computers in our country & full broad band connectivity is a dream . |
|
1 2 |
|
|
|
|